Project

General

Profile

Actions

Feature #1316

closed

Feature: It should be possible to set a comment of an issue as "done"

Added by Sepp _ almost 16 years ago. Updated almost 16 years ago.

Status:
Closed
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
-
Category:
-
Target version:
-
Start date:
2008-05-28
Due date:
% Done:

0%

Estimated time:
Resolution:
Wont fix

Description

Feature: It should be possible to set a comment of an issue as "done".

When discussing issues, we often define a more detailed worktask aftera issue has already been filed.
it would be nice to set an comment as "done", so that other readers of the bug know more about the state and know, which part of the issue is already resolved, when it has ~50%

Actions #1

Updated by Maxim Krušina almost 16 years ago

Hi, what's stopping you to write comment "done" in the right time?
Adding functionality to add note "done" when task is in cca 50% doesnt make so much sense.
Anyway, when you change ticket state, there is always automatic note on change state in comments history, so it's practically whar you want, isn't it?

It looks like this:
  • Status changed from New to Resolved
Actions #2

Updated by Sepp _ almost 16 years ago

But when you only solved 50% of an issue, how do you tell someone who newly reads the issue, which 50% are solved, and witch needs to be worked on?

I idea was to say: "You don't have to read and understand comment #1, because it is already fixed. But you need to read comment #2 and #3 to solve the last 50%".

Does it now make more sense ;-)?

Actions #3

Updated by Maxim Krušina almost 16 years ago

I guess I understand... actually you are suggesting something like "subtasking"... IMHO it's much more better to stick to current sollution, so you create three independent issues, which you can link by dependencies, category or so. Implementing logic you are sugesting will create much complicated logic - you will understand this logic well, but for most of users it will became overcomplicated.

One of best things on Redmine is, that it's really straightforward and self-explaining application, so almost everybody will understand how it works without any fat books etc... it this way (and in lot of other ways ;) Redmine really rocks!

Actions #4

Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang almost 16 years ago

  • Status changed from New to Closed
  • Resolution set to Wont fix

I agree with Maxim. See request #443 about subtasking.

Actions #5

Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang almost 16 years ago

Optionnaly, you can also edit the note and add something like this:

DONE

Actions

Also available in: Atom PDF