Defect #607


Problems with UI design of selection and right-click behaviour in the issue list

Added by M T about 16 years ago. Updated about 16 years ago.

Target version:
Start date:
Due date:
% Done:


Estimated time:
Affected version:


There are a few usability problems with the way this works:

  1. The way that bulk editing is accessed with the pencil icon at the top of the checkbox column is rather non-intuitive and seems a bit idiosyncratic. It would be more conventional to select/clear all checkboxes using this icon?
  2. Right clicking on an issue to access the context menu should obey the checkboxes, so that it is possible, for example, to do a bulk edit or move of issues. (The business of holding down the Control key to select multiple issues, if that ever worked in the past, does not seem to work now).
  3. Not possible with this AJAX technique to get to the right-click browser menu that allows for opening the issue in a new window. This is extremely useful. Without this, if you're working your way through a whole set of issues, you have to keep re-running your query! Painful! One option would be to add a new option to the right-click application menu to open the issue (in a new window or tab)

Related issues

Related to Redmine - Feature #563: Issues bulk move feature requestClosed

Related to Redmine - Feature #567: To turn on the checkbox of all issuesClosed

Related to Redmine - Feature #545: Issues Context menuClosed

Actions #1

Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang about 16 years ago

I agree concerning 1 and 2:
  • the pencil should be used to toggle the selection
  • the right-click menu would propose an additionnal 'Bulk edit' item if the selection contains more than one issue, to be able to change multiple properties on a set of issues. The actual 'Bulk edit' form would be displayed when clicking this menu item.
Concerning 3, I see 3 solutions:
  • the one you propose (as requested here: #545)
  • to not show the context menu when right clicking on the issue link (but only when clicking anywhere else on the table row)
  • use ctrl + click (works fine with firefox)
Actions #2

Updated by M T about 16 years ago

With point (3), either the first or second mechanism would be acceptable.

Re the ctrl+click: I use Firefox, and I cannot get the ctrl+click method to work at all!! Maybe I'm not doing it right? Perhaps you could clarify exactly what you are supposed to do just in case I'm doing it wrong. Perhaps this technique is a bit flakey?

The main thing is that the right-click menu obeys the does not at present. And we need to be able to bulk move.

Actions #3

Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang about 16 years ago

I just use Ctrl + left-click on the issue link and firefox opens the issue details view in a new tab.
It's a default firefox shortcut:

And it works with safari as well.

Actions #4

Updated by M T about 16 years ago

Ah OK - I didn't know you could do that...that solves one issue. But for completeness it would be nice to have it on the app menu as well.

But it doesn't address the issue of being able to do a bulk move of issues from one project to another. There is no way to do this as things stand is there?

Actions #5

Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang about 16 years ago

  • Status changed from New to 7
  • Assignee set to Jean-Philippe Lang

I'm working on it.

It will be possible to select multiple tickets by using Ctrl or Shit keys when clicking on the rows, or by using checkboxes.
Right-clicking on a set of issues will let you bulk edit or move the selected tickets.

Actions #6

Updated by M T about 16 years ago

Excellent - looking forward to it.

Actions #7

Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang about 16 years ago

  • Status changed from 7 to Closed

Issues can now be bulk edited/moved/deleted and all the problems you mentionned about the UI are fixed.
See r1130.


Also available in: Atom PDF