Defect #12968
Subtasks don't resepect following/precedes
| Status: | Closed | Start date: | ||
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Priority: | Normal | Due date: | ||
| Assignee: |  Jean-Philippe Lang | % Done: | 0% | |
| Category: | Issues planning | |||
| Target version: | 2.3.0 | |||
| Resolution: | Fixed | Affected version: |
Description
In the current development version, there is a bug
Imagine following scenario:
There are 2 tasks: "Issue1" and "Issue2", and "Issue2" follows "Issue 1" by x days. This works fine. But if I add an subtask to "Issue2" the startdate is not correctly set to Issue1.enddate + x, instead it is possible to set any date you want, without respecting the Issue Relation.
Furthermore, it is possible to set a relation so the subtask precedes "Issue 1", which creates a circular dependency.
Associated revisions
Fixed: subtasks don't resepect following/precedes relations on creation (#12968).
History
#1
Updated by Daniel Felix almost 8 years ago
I encountered some error which seems to relates to the same problem.
For example:
- Task A
-- Task A1
-- Task A2
- Task B
-- Task B1
-- Task B2
- Task C
Task C follows A, Task B1 follows C, Task B2 follows B1
If I set some follow or precede on subtask, where the parent task already has precedes or follows relations, these relations will be automatically removed without any warning or errormessage. I encountered this several times.
#2
Updated by Daniel Felix over 7 years ago
- Target version set to 2.3.0
This should be rechecked before 2.3 release.
Can anyone still confirm this?
#3
Updated by Moe H over 7 years ago
I have rewritten the all_dependent_issues function in the issue model, which should eliminate the problem with circular dependency. But i'm not sure how to contribute it.
#4
Updated by Daniel Felix over 7 years ago
Hi,
Maybe your firm with tortoise. Just generate a diff with your changes.
If not, just upload a file with the corresponding function.
Maybe toshi or jean-Philippe can review this and apply the changes to the core.
This way it could be fixed before Redmine 2.3 will be released.
#5
Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang over 7 years ago
- Status changed from New to Resolved
- Assignee set to Jean-Philippe Lang
- Resolution set to Fixed
Moe H wrote:
In the current development version, there is a bug
Imagine following scenario:
There are 2 tasks: "Issue1" and "Issue2", and "Issue2" follows "Issue 1" by x days. This works fine. But if I add an subtask to "Issue2" the startdate is not correctly set to Issue1.enddate + x, instead it is possible to set any date you want, without respecting the Issue Relation.
Fixed in r11640.
Furthermore, it is possible to set a relation so the subtask precedes "Issue 1", which creates a circular dependency.
Fixed as part of #8794.
Thanks for pointing this out.