Defect #6625
closed
Attachments lost when activity field error occures
0%
Description
If there is activity field error (set Timelog, but not set Activity type) Redmine does not save attached files and I need attach it once again.
Files
Related issues
Updated by Holger Just about 14 years ago
This was introduced in r3305.
I think it is rather hard to really say which of the two cases is better:- throw the file away and thus have atomic update operations
- attach the file nevertheless the other fields are invalid
The second case is better for larger files where uploading can take some significant time, the first case fits the currently designed workflow better, where we have atomic operations everywhere in Redmine.
Updated by Maxim Strukov about 14 years ago
Redmine can check the field before sending to the server without reloading page? In this case file will still not loaded, but already choosed and ready for upload.
Updated by 
Updated by Peter Englmaier almost 13 years ago
This issue seems not to be worked on and is still present in Redmine 1.2.2.stable.7811.
Please add the issue to the 'Candidate for next minor release' list!
Updated by Go MAEDA over 9 years ago
- Status changed from New to Closed
- Resolution set to Fixed
Probably implemented in r10977 and 10977 (Redmine 2.3).
In current versions, attachments are kept even after validation errors.