Defect #7127: Project completion on gantt is wrong - Redmine

Actions

Copy link

Defect #7127

open

Project completion on gantt is wrong

Added by Jean-Philippe Lang almost 14 years ago. Updated about 11 years ago.

Status:

Needs feedback

Priority:

Normal

Assignee:

Category:

Gantt

Target version:

Start date:

2010-12-18

Due date:

% Done:

Estimated time:

Resolution:

Affected version:

Description

The project completion shown on the chart gantt (implemented in Project#completed_percent) is kind of broken:

it doesn't take issues without target version into account
it does a simple average of all versions completions, whereas it should do a weighted calculation based on issue progress/estimate, just like it is done for versions completion.

This is not that hard to fix but that would make the gantt a bit more slow. So the question is: do we keep project completion display on the gantt?

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Jean-Philippe Lang almost 14 years ago

Target version deleted (~~1.1.0~~)

Project completion disabled in r4582 for 1.1. Will be added back if fixed and needed.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Daniel Felix almost 12 years ago

Due date set to 2013-01-22
Status changed from New to Needs feedback

This seems to be fixed already due to all the changes which applied to the gantt modul.

Any regression? Otherwise I will close this next week.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Mischa The Evil almost 12 years ago

Due date deleted (~~2013-01-22~~)

Daniel Felix wrote:

This seems to be fixed already due to all the changes which applied to the gantt modul.

I can't remember any changeset that fixed Project#completed_percent. What changes are you referring to?

Any regression? Otherwise I will close this next week.

The 'regression' was introduced in Redmine 1.1.0 and is still present up to at least 2.1.0.stable.10438 (tested on m.redmine.org).
I'll remove the due date you've set.

Since it seems nobody has actually has missed this feature (which was originally implemented with r4072 for #6276) for over more than two years we could argue that the second condition from the proposition to restore the feature in a future version hasn't been met:

Jean-Philippe Lang wrote:

[...] Will be added back if fixed and needed.

Following the above I think the proper status for this issue at the moment is "Needs feedback" indeed. If anyone wants this feature back in they need to increase activity on this issue.
In general, I don't think it is good to close this issue while the (to-be) obsoleted code is still in.

Note: while testing on m.redmine.org I also got some 'goofy' results with the line showing when a Project is active. Though this falls outside the scope of this issue.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Daniel Felix almost 12 years ago

Mischa The Evil wrote:

Daniel Felix wrote:

This seems to be fixed already due to all the changes which applied to the gantt modul.

I can't remember any changeset that fixed Project#completed_percent. What changes are you referring to?

Sorry, I meaned the patches provided by Tobias Droste. :-)
There are some patches, which fix some bugs regarding Gantt.

Actions

Copy link

Updated by Mischa The Evil almost 12 years ago

Daniel Felix wrote:

Mischa The Evil wrote:

Daniel Felix wrote:

This seems to be fixed already due to all the changes which applied to the gantt modul.

I can't remember any changeset that fixed Project#completed_percent. What changes are you referring to?

Sorry, I meaned the patches provided by Tobias Droste. :-)
There are some patches, which fix some bugs regarding Gantt.

You mean the patches attached to issues #347 and #12730? I did a quick scan of these patches but they doesn't seem to fix the 'regression' nor the specific bugs as described in the list in this issue's description.

Actions

Copy link