Feature #6974
open
Define manually the versions order in Roadmap (when date isn't defined)
0%
Description
Hi,
in my project, I've many versions in my Roadmap.
Actually version are ordered by date and by title.
In my project, I don't define release date, however I would like to define the versions order.
Is it possible to append this feature ?
Regards,
Stephane
Files
Related issues
Updated by Dipan Mehta over 11 years ago
+100. This is a very critical functionality.
Version name (automated) sorting has been an issue with debates and still there seems no universally accepted way. See related issues: #11153 vs. #12814. What is otherwise not reported but becomes even more mess when there are multiple projects sharing their versions across tree/hierarchy and none has a date for it!
Other related issues are: #6881, #7269, #8080
The trouble is, there won't ever be a one-fit-solution-for-all. I think best situation can be if the versions are allowed to be explicitly manually ordered on the versions page.
It doesn't take a genius to make it -but might ease everyone's problems.
+100 please implement this.
Updated by Daniel Albuschat about 11 years ago
+1 from me, too.
We use Versions as "Milestones" with descriptive texts, hence an alphabetical order is not useful to us.
We use redmine to plan our projects, too, and there are no due dates while planning.
This means that versions are in a totally useless order while planning a project, which is a real burden to the planner and makes it difficult to talk about a project in the planning phase based on the roadmap.
Updated by ixbidie ixbidie about 11 years ago
+1 too
joining my previous speakers
Updated by chu chu almost 10 years ago
+1
I think most people want least version in top of the list, like
https://github.com/redmine/redmine/releases
or
http://jmeter-plugins.org/downloads/all/
If I made the PR, will you accept it?
Updated by Bryn Jeffries almost 10 years ago
+1
Ideally this should be configurable, but by default the order should by according to the displayed text. I can get what I want by hacking app/models/version.rb to
# Versions are sorted by name
# then by effective date (nulls lose) and then id
def <=>(version)
if name == version.name
if self.effective_date
if version.effective_date
self.effective_date == version.effective_date ? id <=> version.id : self.effective_date <=> version.effective_date
else
1
end
else
-1
end
else
name <=> version.name
end
end
Updated by
Updated by Klavs Klavsen about 7 years ago
Will this ever get accepted into redmine? I'm really missing it :(
Updated by Sunding Wei about 4 years ago
10 years later, I still need this feature desperately.
Updated by Sunding Wei about 4 years ago
- File version-order.png version-order.png added
I finally solved the roadmap versions sorting issue, see the screenshot, assume we always create bigger version each time.
The changed code of: app/models/version.rb
def <=>(version)
if self.effective_date
if version.effective_date
# both have dates
if self.effective_date == version.effective_date
# 1. (v0.1) to (v0.2)
id <=> version.id
else
# 2. (early) to (later)
self.effective_date <=> version.effective_date
end
else
# 3. (date) to (no date)
-1
end
else
if version.effective_date
# 4. (date) to (no date)
1
else
# 5. both no dates, order by id descent
version.id <=> id
end
end
end
Updated by Holger Just almost 2 years ago
- Related to Feature #1137: Project version added