Redmine

Any update / progress on this?

+1

+1

Redmine Code Review Plugin has this feature.
http://www.r-labs.org/projects/r-labs/wiki/Code_Review_en

+1

+1

Toshi MARUYAMA wrote:

Redmine Code Review Plugin has this feature.
http://www.r-labs.org/projects/r-labs/wiki/Code_Review_en

This plugin is very good solution. I think there is no need to implement other functionality for comments. Moreover, commits come with comments from SCM.

-1

+1
I would love to see this bundled in redmine. Right now not having it (ok, plugin) is the only cause for me to install gitlab.

+1. This is really a good idea.

I would like to point out one thing: While this sounds like a close equivalent of "Code Review Plugin" it is certainly not.

1. Code Reviews are NOT limited to only 1 revision but could be for an entire set of Revisions
2. Code Review is a formal process - and usually it implies that code-reviews are done typically in a project's collective decisions, approvals and it involves many people beyond developers!
3. Usually, "Code Review Assignments" registers an issue which then someone really have to attend, follow through its formal process, may be include tests and so on.
4. At best "Comments on the Revisions" - are actually a poor replacements for the Code Review. - but that is the reason why they are very important.

The reason why 'Comments on Revisions' is so important is that it allows informal communication between those involved without having to worry about organization's other processes!

+1 This feature must be there as Redmine's ability.

+1