Project

General

Profile

Actions

Feature #3952

open

Filtering by subproject still shows current project's issues

Feature #3952: Filtering by subproject still shows current project's issues

Added by Rahul Vaidya about 17 years ago. Updated 9 months ago.

Status:
New
Priority:
Normal
Assignee:
-
Category:
Issues filter
Target version:
-
Resolution:

Description

Set a filter for Subproject is <subprojectname>. The current parent project's issues will still be shown. Issue seen in trunk.


Related issues 5 (0 open — 5 closed)

Related to Redmine - Defect #5388: Filtering by subproject seems to not workClosedActions
Related to Redmine - Defect #8853: Filter on subproject does not workClosedActions
Related to Redmine - Defect #41193: Incorrect time calculation in subprojectClosedActions
Has duplicate Redmine - Defect #29596: Filter by subproject not workingClosedActions
Follows Redmine - Defect #2512: Subproject filter do not workClosedMischa The EvilActions

Updated by Ewan Makepeace almost 17 years ago Actions #1

+1

[This has been previously been flagged as by design in #2512 - but I feel is a mistake. Personally I need to be able to view subproject issues and exclude those not assigned to any subproject. This is currently impossible - moreover the current behavior is extremely counter intuitive since the filter field clearly says you should only be seeing subproject issues, and so this will continue to be reported as a bug I suspect...]

Updated by Mischa The Evil almost 17 years ago Actions #2

  • Tracker changed from Defect to Feature

Updated by Mischa The Evil almost 17 years ago Actions #3

I've changed this to be a feature request instead of being a defect (a new design-change is requested).

Updated by Nigel Jones over 16 years ago Actions #4

+1
I ran into this bug immediately after adding a subproject to an existing project - it makes subprojects less useful

Updated by Gerry Hawkins about 16 years ago Actions #5

(running 1.0.1)
+1
I disagree with the 'this is not a bug, but by design' response.
If you read the from the filter UI: "Show issues where the status is open and the subproject is B", where B is a subproject of A and I am doing this filter in A, I expect to see issues that are open and only in subproject B.

I appreciate the comment that if I want to filter to see just issues in the sub project I should go there, but I feel that the UI as it exists misrepresents what is probably a more common expectation. "is" implies equals. If you changed the all/none/is pull down to be all/none/including/excluding then I would say the UI and workflow would be OK. But still not what I would like. ;-)

Updated by Terence Mill about 16 years ago Actions #6

In general you sould be able to search and filter all tickets in the current project you are at the moment and its subprojects.

There are 3 search type one would use in this context.

  1. Search in current project and its siblings
  2. Search only in current project without its siblings
  3. Search in a specific subproject (of current project and) its siblings > this excludes all tickets above the subproject till this project going upwards the tree
  4. Search in a specific subproject (which belongs to current project) without its siblings

1. is possible by default and 3. can be achived by junping to subproject and doing as in 1.

How can 3. and 4. be achieved at the moment?

Updated by Kevin Palm almost 11 years ago Actions #7

+1

Updated by Go MAEDA almost 10 years ago Actions #8

  • Category changed from Issues to Issues filter

Updated by Mischa The Evil almost 10 years ago Actions #9

  • Related to Defect #8853: Filter on subproject does not work added

Updated by Phil Valentine almost 9 years ago Actions #10

+1

I too was bemused when my filter did not do as I expected.
Filter say show me things that are:
Staus=Open
SubProject=SubprojectA

With this setup I did not expect to see issues that were related to the parent project.

Updated by Marius BĂLTEANU over 7 years ago Actions #11

  • Has duplicate Defect #29596: Filter by subproject not working added

Updated by Nat D over 3 years ago Actions #12

+1
As manager of multiple projects monitored by my business unit (having its project parent of mines), I would like to filter (only) on these projects and not on the current one.

I thought that there is no way to filter with "OR", only "AND" and this behavior looks like an "OR" filter: current project OR subproject = "my subproject"...

Updated by Holger Just about 2 years ago Actions #13

  • Related to Defect #41193: Incorrect time calculation in subproject added

Updated by Peter Volkov 9 months ago Actions #14

Can we reconsider this design? There is even a patch in #8853.

Jean-Phillipe Lang also expressed doubts in #5388-1: "Maybe we should change this behaviour."

But we still have this behaviour, why? Current behaviour is very unintuitive. To avoid breakages for those who rely on current behaviour, it's possible to adda new filter...

Actions

Also available in: PDF Atom